As Week 3 of the NFL season arrives, fantasy football managers are debating whether to start Keon Coleman or Khalil Shakir when the Buffalo Bills face the Miami Dolphins on Thursday Night Football. Both receivers had slow outings in Week 2, leaving fantasy owners with questions heading into this divisional matchup.
Why Consider Keon Coleman?
Coleman opened the season with an impressive debut against Baltimore, recording eight receptions for 112 yards and a touchdown. His chemistry with quarterback Josh Allen was evident, as he led the team in targets. Although he struggled in Week 2 against New York’s elite secondary, the talent is there for Coleman to bounce back. Against Miami’s defense, which has shown vulnerability against explosive plays, Coleman could once again emerge as Allen’s go-to deep threat and red-zone option.
Concerns About Coleman
Consistency remains the biggest concern for fantasy players. After his strong Week 1, Coleman was quiet in Week 2, managing only three catches for 26 yards. Buffalo’s offense also features several other playmakers, including James Cook and Dalton Kincaid, which makes Coleman’s target share less predictable.
Why Consider Khalil Shakir?
Shakir has been building trust with Josh Allen since last season, when he delivered over 800 receiving yards and four touchdowns. As a reliable route runner with strong hands, he offers stability in the short-to-intermediate passing game. Against Miami, Shakir could see a steady volume of targets, especially if Coleman struggles with coverage or drops.
Concerns About Shakir
Shakir doesn’t bring the same big-play upside near the goal line that Coleman does. With multiple red-zone weapons on the roster, his opportunities to score may be limited. If Buffalo leans heavily on explosive plays or ground-and-pound rushing, Shakir could have a modest fantasy day.
Final Verdict
For Week 3, Coleman carries the higher ceiling while Shakir offers the safer floor. If you need upside and are willing to take a risk, start Keon Coleman. If your lineup already feels strong and you just need stability, Khalil Shakir is a steady option.
0 Comments